El Morro gets all the love. Oh my lord, how they go on. If the Brady Bunch filmed a Very Special Episode in San Juan, Jan would complain, “El Morro, El Morro, El Morro!” I mean, it is the postcard pick, the skyline star, the Instagram trophy.
Which is probably why Castillo San Cristóbal surprised me. I hadn’t heard of it, not really. Only in passing, as in “Don’t forget, your ticket to El Morro gets you into Castillo San Cristóbal, too.” Travel blogs rarely say more than the basics—some tour tips and a bit of dusty history.
But I wanted to see it. Mostly because it had “Castillo” in its name, and castles are cool. (My Spanish isn’t 100%.) So I wandered in on a beautiful, breezy, blue-sky morning in April and was swallowed whole by the biggest Spanish fortification in the New World. And I don’t say that lightly. The thing is bigger than El Morro. More complex. More functional. Less show pony, more war horse.
El Morro guarded the harbor because Spain—Global Superpower of the Seas, Master of the Atlantic, and the generally smug owner of the World’s Most Powerful Armada—couldn’t even conceive of a threat that didn’t arrive by ship. They built their (pretty impressive) fort in 1539, and it stood as San Juan’s only real line of defense for nearly a century—blind to the fact that someone could just land up the shore and walk in.
Which is exactly what the Dutch did.
In 1625, a Dutch fleet under Boudewijn Hendricksz landed near La Puntilla, on the south end of town—basically the opposite side of El Morro. They walked up the hill and seized most of San Juan within 48 hours. El Morro held firm, but the rest of the city folded fast. The Dutch probably assumed Spain would just hand over the deed and call it a day.
The Dutch torched the governor’s mansion and squatted in the capital for more than a month. Governor Juan de Haro and the Spanish forces had retreated into El Morro and spent the time launching counterattacks. The Dutch eventually gave up—not because they were defeated, but because dysentery, low supplies, and the oppressive Caribbean humidity finally broke their will.
Spain had been humiliated, and San Cristóbal was the crown’s forceful answer. They started building San Cristóbal in 1634—a virtual blink of an eye in empire time—just in case anyone else got ideas. The Spanish didn’t just want to plug a hole—they wanted a fortress so thick, sprawling, and geometrically unforgiving that no one would ever try that again.
But this wasn’t a single-decade job. It grew in phases, evolving with each new threat. Over the next 150 years, the fort morphed from a simple defensive triangle into a complex labyrinth of angled walls, dry moats, secret tunnels, and overlapping fields of fire. By 1783, it was a 27-acre monster stretching along the eastern edge of Old San Juan. It was its own fortified district of the city carved into the hillside, bristling with cannons and peppered with garitas, those stubby stone sentry posts perched along the walls.
Which made it a downright surreal when the fort’s own artillery brigade turned those cannons inward and staged a mutiny over unpaid wages and miserable conditions in 1885, seizing the fortress and threatening to shell the very city it was meant to protect. That’s not the sort of thing they highlight in the educational brochure, but I’d argue it deserves more fanfare than the gift shop’s plush coquí frogs—those chirpy little mascots of Puerto Rican nationalism.
By May 1898, hostilities were already well underway in Cuba. But San Cristóbal opened Puerto Rico’s chapter of the war, firing on the approaching USS Yale. It was a symbolic volley, mostly, but one that signaled the final collapse of Spanish dominance in the Caribbean. Within months, Puerto Rico joined Cuba, the Philippines, and Guam in America's rapidly expanding overseas portfolio.
But the Castillo didn’t fade away into ruins like so many colonial relics do. Instead, it stayed active. The U.S. Army moved in immediately after annexation and used it as a working military base for decades. They ran communications from inside the tunnels, and during World War II, they built a fire control station and bunker system right into the walls. If you wander the top level today, you’ll see 18th-century garitas sitting next to mid-20th-century concrete pillboxes with their characteristic narrow firing slits, colonial stonework, and Cold War concrete smooshed together. Even the old cisterns were updated, doubling as fallout shelters early in the Cold War.
The site wasn’t decommissioned until 1961, having served three centuries of military purpose. And it shows. There's a functional military bluntness to San Cristóbal that hasn't yet weathered into quaintness. You feel the age of the place, yes—but also the recency. This wasn't just a stage for colonial ambitions and 19th-century skirmishes. It was a working fortress, tweaked and re-used, patched over and repurposed, well into the age of atomic paranoia.
That might be why it feels less performative than El Morro. The views are still spectacular, and the breeze still whips off the water like it’s been scripted, but there's less preening here. Fewer staged moments. More grit. The tunnels are damp. The stones are scarred. The history hasn't been polished for public consumption in quite the same way, and you can feel it as you move through the layers. No audio tour could explain it better than the echo of your footsteps bouncing off barrel-vaulted ceilings or the stray iguana sunning itself next to a rusted latch.
I honestly hadn’t planned on staying long. I thought I’d do a quick lap, snap some photos, and move on. To El Morro, duh. But three hours slipped by before I even checked my watch. That’s San Cristóbal’s best trick. It doesn’t lure you in with fanfare. It just surrounds you, slowly, with stone and silence and everything that happened here—and then leaves you wondering how it was ever upstaged by El Morro. Someone should tell Jan.
Write a comment